Atmopadesa Satakam Verse 1

Verse One

Rising even above knowledge, what
within the form
Of the one who knows, as equally
without, radiant shines,
To that Core, with eyes five restrained
within,
Again and again prostrating in adoration,
one should chant.

The inquiry begins with the introduction of the “Core” which has several unique properties. First of all this core is not dull or opaque, but “radiantly shines”.  We consider our knowledge as our highest realm.  It is in pursuit of knowledge that we undertake all kinds of disciplines. We also identify ourself with our knowledge.  Our knowledge defines who we are.  The “Core” however, rises beyond the limits of our knowledge.  It is therefore both in and beyond our knowledge.  There is also parity between the inner and outer aspects, or the subjective and objective aspects of our knowledge.  Therefore this “Core” is unitive and indivisible even though it appears to be divided as a subject and an object.

The second half of the verse tells us to prostrate before this Core with the five senses restrained.  Thus our search is not to be conducted in the outer world which is experienced through the five senses.  We should explore the content of our consciousness within.

It also rises above the knowlege I" consciousness, which seems to be the core of the consciousness within one's physical being and also the point of reference with which everything outside is related for one's awareness of the external world.  The same core is also to be seen as the all-pervading stuff of pure consciousness which is indivisible and yet is the only content of all this is objectively and subjectively visualized.

The core of consciousness is like a light which illuminates both the inside and outside.  Everything that is experienced in the objective world has a correspondence with what is experienced in the subjective world, even though the converse of it is not true.

There is a vertical ascent from all relative forms of knowledge to arrive finally at a state of realization.  The external world is related to the sense organs, and they have their subjective counterparts in the sense impressions.  The subjective counterpart, however, has other aspects other than the mere production of copies of replicas of the external world.  This is to be dealt with later.

This verse summarizes the attitude of a Guru who teaches by his Word.  A person who wants to teach with words has to retain his personal ego as a point of reference.  At the same time, what he has to teach is that which goes beyond all knowledge.  So he also has to surrender his ego to the Self that is shining within him as the Guru.  He has to continuously surrender and with an attitude of eternal reverence pay homage to the Supreme.  Here the Guru does not claim that he is teaching.  His word is representing the revelation of the Supreme.

The supreme truth is not the product of ratiocination.  It is perennial and it's validity is independent of the man through whom it is revealed.  That is why the Guru here us the term "chant."



Verse Two

The inner organ, the senses, and counting
from the body
The many worlds we know are all,
on thought, the sacred form
Of the Supreme Sun risen in the void
beyond;
By relentless cogitation, one should
attain to this.


Western physiology and psychology think of knowledge as something that registers on the mind from the external world.  According to this verse, knowledge begins with a selective and subjective structuring.  The last in the series is the external world.

All knowledge begins with the four-fold inner organ.  The four aspects of the inner organ are:
1. Manas, which is the interrogating or inquiring aspect of consciousness.
2. Citta, which is that aspect of consciousness that memorizes and recalls.
3. Buddhi, which is the aspect of consciousness that judges and arrives at certitude.
4. Ahamkara, which is the ego factor that is affected positively or negatively or neutrally.  The sense organs do not operate unless they are commissioned by the inner organ.  Then alone comes the world of external objects and the various universes of interest.

The human mind traverses from one universe of interest to another.  Guru takes the analogy of the light that becomes identical with the forms of things it illuminates as analogous with the one Supreme Consciousness, which is seen as apparently transforming itself into the several forms of itself.  At night we see only a dark world o outside with no light to illuminate it.  When sunlight comes we see clearly the hills and maybe a lake, and boats and trees.  That does not mean that the sun produced the hills or water or boat.  They do not have any light to shine by themselves - the sun illuminates them.

In other words, what we see as the sky and hills and lake is nothing but light, identified with the colors and shapes of all these particular things.  It is the one light that shines on all these.  The external light that falls on a tree enables an eye to see the tree.  Though we think that we are seeing the tree, we actually see only a visual image falling on our eye that is none other than the sunlight that is reflected by the tree.  This is a case of the light transforming into an object.  What is the sun in the physical sky is the Self shining by its own light in the void of consciousness.


Verse Three

These phenomenal aspects five, such
as the sky,
When as emergent from outside is here
seen to be,
By contemplation one should bring to
non-difference,
As the sea is to the waves that rise
in rows thereon.

What is hinted at in the previous verse is made more explicit in this verse in which everything seen as external is pointed out ad a projection in psychological time and space.  Physical space and time and the objectivity of things are assumptions, and the only fact of which we are sure is our subjective impressions, which are at best only mental images and abstracted language symbols.    

Verse Six (Draft)

dhanuh pauspam mauve madhukaramayi panca visikha
vasantah samanto malaya marud ayodhanarathah
tathapya ekah sarvam himagiri sute kam api krpam
apangat te labdhva jagat idam anango vijayate

O Daughter of the Snowy Peak, just deriving from your
glance askance whatsoever grace he could,
With flowery bow and bumblebee string,
and five-flowered dart and springtide for minister,
All these as one withal, mounting the chariot
of the mountain breeze, he victorious reigns, the god of love.

Beauty is experienced in the mind. The object may be situated in space-time, but the value, "ananda" is experienced within a person. The mind is, therefore, the focus of contemplation. The mind has been studied for many thousands of years, and yet its mysteries are not fully understood. One type of study focuses on the healthy state of mind and the yogis and wise individuals are sought as exemplars of high mindedness. Another kind of study looks at people who are suffering from disease and their minds are studied and the cause of their illness is diagnosed.

In the Saundarya Lahari, we are introduced to a very highly developed aesthetic of an elevated state of profound beauty. The mind is like a mirror, reflecting both the world experienced outside and the thoughts and feelings within. The inward value that is experienced is the same for all individuals, but the external causes can be different. This can cause confusion and conflict as people wrongly thing that they are appreciating different things. Yes and No. There is variety in the object of appreciation, but unity in the inward appreciation of value.

Keats famously declared that a thing of beauty is a joy forever. Eternity is inexhaustible beauty - a wonder that never ceases. Where is beauty to be found? In the eye of the beholder, say the poets.

Unlike a physical mirror which remains unchanged while reflecting the surroundings, the mind, with its basis in consciousness, is a medium, a thinking substance, that transforms into its reflection. Vrittis, or modulations of the mind, assume the form of the subject and the object. A common analogy is that of amorphous clay becoming a pot or a cup. Once the form is assumed, the features of form so impresses the mind that it looses its ability to discern the universal "stuff" which has no specificity. So the flexible mind can change into any word formation or emotion without loosing it's intrinsic nature. The rigid mind is forced to keep itself from changing, and this inflexibility becomes it's own prison.

When a form has a certain sensibility, it looks beautiful. In this verse Daughter of the Snowy Peak refers to Parvati. She is the daughter of "parvata", the mountain. We find references in Indian mythology to the feminine connection with the earth. Sita of the Ramayana is born in a furrow and eventually returns to the earth. Here the Universal Goddess is identified with Parvati. The second reference is to Kama, the god of love. Kamadeva needs the side glance of the Goddess in order to be able to function.

The god of love mentioned here is an elemental spirit, closer to nature, the forces of which he needs to accomplish his influence. But the powers of nature are not enough by themselves, he needs the grace of the Universal Mother in order to be able to function. She grants him this grace by a side glance, which is enough, even though it is much inferior to a full glance.

Here is love portrayed in its healthy and divine expression. The energy of the spring season brings great delight to the human heart. The sweet call of birds, the cool refreshing breezes, the fragrance of flowers have a slightly intoxicating effect. This is just the occasion thay the god of love is looking for to shoot his flowery arrows. Thus the factor of occasionalism is very important for the success of Kamadeva.

His bow is also made of flowers, and the bowstring is made of a row of bees. There is a drop of nectar in every flower which the bee seeks. The bees fly back and forth, with a buzzing sound, very much like the twang of a bowstring as it is pulled back and released.

The five-flowered arrow cannot cause any physical injury, but they make people fall madly in love. This is a 'wound ' with a peculiar agony, and paradoxically solace only comes from the very source that caused the wound in the first place.

The poets Kalidasa and Jayadeva are masters at describing the mental and physical state of lovers as they go through the pangs and ecstasy of their relationships.

Poetry offers us a medium to express the subtler aspects of the mind in a symbolic language which has a deeper meaning than prose. To be able to perceive the deeper structure of language and associate words with their truer meanings is the gift of the poet. The poet, like other artists, is therefore able to see much more than a non-poet. This insight is arrived at by deep pondering and penetration.

Some Notes from "The Living Goddesses" by Maria Gimbutas

In Neolithic Europe and Asia Minor (ancient Anatolia) in the era between 7000 BC and 3000 BC religion focused on the wheel of life and it's cyclical turning. This is the geographic sphere and the time frame I refer to as Old Europe. In Old Europe, the focus of religion encompassed birth, nurturing, growth, death,and regeneration, as well as crop cultivation and the raising of animals. The people of this era pondered untamed natural forcers, as well as wild plant and animal cycles, and they worshiped goddesses, or a goddess, in many forms. The goddess manifested her countless forms during various cyclical phases to ensure that they functioned smoothly. She revealed herself in multiple ways through the myriad facets of life, and she is depicted in a very complex symbolism.

First I will explore these forms in detail, looking mainly at goddess figures, and then I will unravel their meaning. The images of the goddess can be loosely categorized under her aspect of life giving and sustaining, death, and renewal. Although male energy also motivated regeneration and life stimulation, in both the plant and animal worlds, it was the feminine force that pervaded existence.

The human body constituted one of Old Europe's most powerful symbols. As a result of modern cultural programming, we often associate nakedness with sexual enticement. The modern analyst naturally projects these attitudes back thousands of years and assumes that ancient depictions of the body served basically the same purpose.

Writing grew out of religious symbols and signs. Humans have been communicating by means of symbols for a very long time. Abstract signs emerge in the Lower Paleolithic Acheulin and Mousterian periods ( from circa 300,000 to 100,000 bc)

The scandanavian magician priestess known as Thor Volva had a council of nine wise women.

In some areas like Minoan Crete and the Agean Islands a completely theacentric, gynocentric civilization and religion endured through the first half of the second millennium bc.




Krishna tends to Radha's feet

Saundaryan Lahari Verse 5

haris tram aradhya pranata saubhagya jananim
pura nari bhutva pura ripum api ksobham anayat
smaro'pi tvam natva rati nayana lehyena vapusa
muninam apy antah prabhavatim mohaya mahatam


O Great Mother, once the great Mahavisnu, having
worshipped you (well known as the bestower of happiness on all those who are devoted to you),
changed himself into a woman of exquisite beauty.
He caused agitation even in the mind of the great Siva,
well known for his restraint as the burner of the three cities.
Kama, the god of love, whose body is invisible,
smears his erotic enjoyability on those whom he chooses;
they are licked by the goddess of erotics and thereby
confusion is caused, even in the minds of the great sages
who are well established in their meditations.




Commentary

The Universal Mother is praised here as the bestower of blessings on those who worship her. There are two other references: one to the myth of the Churning of the Milk ocean and the other to Kamadeva, the God of Love.

The Churning of the Milk ocean by the Devas and the Asuras produced the pot of the elixir of immortality. In Kalidasa's poem "Kumarasambhava", Siva burns Kama, the god of love, to ashes. Moved by the laments of Kama's consort Rati, the Goddess allows Kama to exist in a bodiless form. This has reference to the effect of love on a person, which like hunger has no particular location and can suddenly afflict a person. Kama is also known as Smara, which means memory, and Siva is also known as Smarahara, the destroyer of Smara. Memory preserves the continuity of our experience, but becomes an obstacle when we want to experience universal consciousness.

The Milk Ocean is the abode of Visnu and the realm of all specific values. Both the Devas and the Asuras, the bright and dark forces, are vying with one another for immortality and supremacy over life. Brahma the creator advised them to churn the ocean of life to gain the elixir of immortality. As the churning could not be done by any group separately, it was agreed as a joint venture. The great Mount Mandara was used as the churning rod. The beginningless ocean also has no bottom. Therefore it became necessary to find a ground for the churning rod to rest upon. Visnu being the preserver changed into a turtle and provided that ground. The rope used for churning was none other than the great serpent Ananta, endless time. The Devas held the tail and the Asuras held the head of the serpent.

As a result of the churning, fourteen precious things appeared one after the other: the celestial white elephant, airavata; the mace, gada; the parijata tree, kaumodaki; the white horse, uccaissravas; the desire-granting cow, kamadhenu; the conch shell, sankha; the crescent moon, candra; goddess of grace and abundance, Laksmi; the great bow, dhanuh; virgin of the stars, Astreya, the jewel of great luster, kasutubha; the celestial nymph of great beauty, Rambha; and finally the god of medicine, Dhanvantri, bearing a pot with the elixir of immortality, amrta.

The churning agitated the snake Ananta and it vomited the world poison, kalakuta. This terrified the Devas and the Asuras. To calm their fears Siva drank the poison and saved the world. Henceforth his neck turned blue because of the poison and he came to be known as Nilakantha, the Blue-Throated.

The Asuras snatched the pot of elixir from the god Dhanvantri and ran away. The Devas did not want the Asuras to become immortal by partaking of the amrta, elixir of immortality. Vishnu turned to the Universal Mother with devotion and appealed for help. By Her grace he was able to transform himself into the very incarnation of beauty named Mohini, the grand seductress. On seeing her charming form, the Asura who had snatched the pot of elixir gladly handed it over and thus the Devas were able to retrieve the amrta.

In this verse Siva is recalling the beautiful form of Vishnu when he had assumed the form of Mohini, the grand seductress, and wants to see that form again. This is referred to as Vishnu causing agitation to Siva.

According to Joseph Campbell, the function of mythology is to waken and maintain in the individual a sense of wonder and participation in the mystery of this finally inscrutable universe.

In this verse we come closer to the subject matter of the Saundarya Lahari which is erotic mysticism. Erotic mysticism is well developed in classical Indian culture. The ancient grassroot traditions existing from pre-Vedic times on the soil of India, worshipped the Goddess. From Babylonia to Egypt, from Crete to the Indus Valley Civilization, we find evidence of Goddess worship through numerous archeological discoveries. Classical Indian culture absorbed the ancient goddess into their culture. This is a very different history from the suppression of the goddess in Medieval European society. The earlier Pagan religions viewed Nature as a theophany, a manifestation of divinity, not a 'fallen' creation of the Creator. The Pagans recognized the female divine principle, called Goddess, with a capital G as well as, or instead of, the male divine principle, god. European Pagan culture also has elements of erotic mysticism but the unfortunate events during Medieval times virtually destroyed it. The rejection of the feminine in favor of the masculine godhead led to a radical shift in the culture and progess of Europe. The witch hunts of the 16th and 17th centuries across Europe finally decimated the grassroot goddess cultures and brutally replaced it with a rationally male mode of thought. The prudery of religion in modern times has alienated human beings from some of their basic biological urges. Among thinkers it was Rousseau who considered human beings to be naturally good, and blamed society as a corrupting influence

Religious doctrines that discredit the value of nature do a great disservice to the dialectical relationship between man and woman. When nature is somehow considered 'inferior' to god, who is turn is thought of as male, the relationship between man and woman becomes lopsided.

Among the great culture creating civilization of the ancient world we have the Egyptian, the Indian, the Greek and the Chinese. These civilizations have vanished, but they have left their imprints in the consciousness of humanity. Modernism has developed in Europe and America and its progress has been fueled by the discovery and utilization of fossil fuels along with scientific and technological developments.

Classical Indian culture excelled in erotic mysticism. The epic Mahabharata has many stories of spontaneous eroticism narrated with honesty. Both dance forms and temple iconography, depicted the gods and goddesses with anabashed eroticism. Classical Indian culture recognized the intrinsic unity of truth, goodness and beauty - satyam, sivam, sundaram. Erotics, srngararasa, is considered to be the most superior and is placed highest amongst the nine aesthetic moods, navarasas. Classical dance and iconographical representations mirror each other, one is fluid and the other frozen -- still images of a dancer's continuous movement -- moments of eternal flux captured in space-time. A talented artist liberates the latent energy of form into freedom through the medium of delightful expression.

Greek culture on the other hand, developed tragedy out of the proto-tragic dithyrambs. The tragic plays of Aeschylus were witnessed by the public who experienced a cathartic release of their suppressed pain and suffering. The emotion release that tragedy provided gave the audience relief from their stress, hardship and privation. Early cinema of the 1940s and 1950s often depicted tragedy. Vittorio De Sica's neorealistic films as well as some early Indian cinema often depicted the reality of life as a tragedy. Shakespeare was deeply influenced by Greek tragedy to write his own tragedies in Elizabethan England. Literature is replete with examples of romantic love, often ending in tragedy. Even today real life love tragedies are reported in daily newspapers.

The modern world massaged by the media prefers glamor and comedy, while tragedy is almost entirely absent from both the cinema and theater. With modern medicine and technology increasing longevity, providing better physical and mental health, and easing the physical drudgery, the accent has moved away from the tragic to the entertaining. Relief is sought in entertainment, recreation, and having fun. Television coverage brings real life tragedy daily into our lives from all over the world and so there is no need for cinema or theatre to point out the nihilistic dimension of life.

Rather than the tragi-comic polarity, classical Indian culture polarised the ascetic with the erotic. Thus Siva is both a supreme ascetic, seated in deep meditation on Mt. Kailasa, and he is also the greatest of lovers depicted in Kalidasa's Kumarasambhava. This inclusive dialectic of "this and that" rather than "this or that" stems from deep understanding of the dialectical interdependence of the apparently polarized nature experienced as the world phenomena. One of the finest depiction of love between Radha and Krishna in found in Jayadeva's "Gita Govinda". As Krishna pulls Radha closer for an embrace in the secrecy of the bower by the banks of the Yamuna river, she shyly resists his embrace, pushing him away with her hands, but is unable to conceal the faint smile of assent on her downturned face. Here is a juxtaposition of innocence and eros, the paradox of love where two opposites unite into a blissful cancellation of counterparts. Their relationship is an expression of Divine Eros, a verticalized sexuality, which inspires music and poetry, dance and romance. This is Keat's "Thing of beauty" that is enjoyed age after age. This is very different from earthly Eros which is horizontal and transient. Earthly eros tends to be gross while heavenly Eros is divine and uplifting. From time immemorial refined cultures around the world have sought the aegis of heavenly Eros as their guiding norm. Divine Eros is grounded in the eternal - the undiminishing well-springs of consciousness, bliss, value, knowledge, sat, cit ananda. There is a continuum, a perennial joy associated with Divine Love. This is called bhauma. Earthy eros has a temporality, a limitation of space and time and a termination followed by recurring need. There is a blissful, explosive ecstatic experience, followed by a diminishing and a fading away, like an elusive moment which can be repeated, but cannot be grasped. This is called tucham, or alpa, small, meagre, little. When the pull of the vertical dimension is weak and the horizontal aspect is preferred, there is physical attraction and gratification, a pleasure pain cycle which ultimately leads to dissipation.

Childhood is lost into adulthood with the first signs of passionate desire to unite with the opposite sex. The playful innocence of childhood is transformed into an irresistible passion, a longing to experience the thrilling dimension of togetherness. But the thrill can be accompanied by negative counterparts like fear and attachment, while social forces can conspire to ruin the relationship. Hunger has no particular location and can affect the entire body. Similarly, the pangs of love afflict the entire personality of a young man or woman. This is the work of the God of Love, whose bodiless form can cause great agitation even in the mind of a great ascetic like Siva.

The union between a man and awoman is akin to the coming together of heaven and earth. Woman is considered closer to nature, while man represents the heavenly spirit. Through the dialectical pairing of man and woman life continues on the planet. Each feels incomplete without the other. The lover and the beloved fulfill each other to experience a sense of wholeness. There is a complementarity, reciprocity, contradiction and cancellation in their dialectical relationship. In the togetherness of their close embrace they slip through time and glimpse the timeless. The dialectics of man and woman, which is at the very foundation of our very existence, is also the fecund ground of paradox. We speak of marriage being made in heaven, or "falling in love". Both these expressions accept the irrational and sudden nature of love between woman and man. Kamadeva shoots his flower-arrows at whomsoever he pleases.

It is said that the language of nature is mathematical. The effects at the experiential level are supported by causal laws that govern the universe. These laws are deterministic and have been understood by mathematicians and scientists and are classified as physical, chemical and biological laws. When we come to human nature we arrive at the threshold of paradox. Within the ambit between wisdom and ignorance there is the possibility of a great amount of variation, making up a composite matrix, displaying a vast range of behavior patterns that can be rational, irrational, stoic, emotional, etc.

In this verse the Devi is using her tongue to lick Kamadeva, the God of Love, into existence. Licking into shape is a very delicate, subtle and intimate way of shaping the god, rather than using the force of the hands or a crude tool. The Goddess's supreme power and position is emphasized here, along with her power to enchant and to enlighten. This has reference to the power of women to generate excitement in the minds of men. Even ascetic minded people find it difficult to avoid the influence of Kamadeva, the God of Love. Visnu takes the form of a beautiful woman to distract the demons when they snatch the ambrosia of immortality from god Dhanvantri as it emerged from the churning of the milk ocean. When Vishnu assumes the form of a grand seductress, Mohini, the demons drop the pot and pursue the beautiful form, which was only a phenomena, a superimposition on Visnu, who was not a woman at all. So is the world a phenomenal projection on a more fundamental reality which is quite different. The foolish are enchanted by the phenomena and in trying to grasp it forget the hidden splendor of their own Self. Such is beauty - a deluding and an emancipating force. Such is the paradox of life around which center problems like the One and the many, being and becoming, and the transcendental and the immanent.

Saundarya Lahari - Preface

I was introduced to the Saundarya Lahari in the 1980s, and have been drawn to the composition over time, often after long gaps. In spite of its allure it did not make much sense to me. Later I was involved in proofreading, indexing and publishing. A serious study only began in 2009. Earlier I had pondered over the text, admired friends who understood its meaning and hoped to have a better understanding myself someday. I had worked on the Index and Bibliography of Nataraja Guru's commentary and I also contributed to the cover design and the structural diagrams for the first 24 verses..

In 2009 I began to chant the first ten verses every evening before retiring for the day. After several weeks of this practice, I began to notice a quantitative change in my consciousness. It was as if something new was being revealed, which was also giving me a very different perspective of life. It was around this time that my good friend Sashi Chandran suggested that I give an introductory class to an interested group in Coimbatore. As we were deciding on a convenient date, I met university scholars in Bangalore and Delhi who were involved with the Saundarya Lahari. It was as if inner and outer circumstances were aligning themselves and gradually the commentary began to yield glimpses of structure and meaning. I found myself feeling a little confident to attempt an interpretation of the first three verses. These verses subsequently became the first class given to a group of twelve women at the Nitya Gurukula, Coimbatore, on 2nd April, 2010. (They are yet to be transcribed for the blog).

The outcome both surprised and inspired me to continue the study and interpretation of the text. It has not morphed into an online commentary which will, I hope, by the Grace of the Supreme Goddess, culminate in a book in due course of time. It is an interesting coincidence that I am commencing this writing in Cambridge, Massachusetts, not far from Harvard University, where Prof. Norman Brown translated and commented on the Saundarya Lahari in 1958 as part of the Harvard Oriental Series.

Saundarya Lahari
Introduction

India has always presents a complex matrix of cross-crossing cultural currents to both the visitor as well as many of her residents. The paradoxical juxtaposition of opposites, often seen side by side, forms a rich tapestry rather than a homogeneous society with easily defined parameters. Any attempt to unravel some of the contradictions draws the seeker at least 30 centuries into the past. Even then the mystery might get even more intriguing rather than resolved. The German philosopher Hegel thought that India did not possess any history as such. True, the records of historical events are rather sketchy and the hagiographical accounts of the past cannot be considered as true history. Yet customs have persisted from the Bronze Age and one can see the happy coexistence of the various strata of history in the practice and the philosophy of the people.

Let us here trace a fairly simple pathway based on current scholarship as well as the insights afforded by the huge body of texts that have survived and the complex practices that are still being followed on the subcontinent.

The earliest strata surviving in the modern world is made up of various tribal communities. Indigenous peoples such the Mundas and the Gonds have a rich tradition of folklore, art and craft as well as knowledge of medicinal plants. This ancient strata forms the earliest layer and the basis for the development of myths, legends, and traditional medicine, which were further refined and classified by later generations.

With the discovery of the The Indus Valley civilization a highly developed urban culture, with refined handicrafts, sophisticated agriculture and contemplative traditions was established. The contemplative proto-Siva model comes from this time, as well as the worship of the goddess. The Indus Valley Civilization was followed by the Vedic overlay, which introduced a host of new gods, new customs and a new social stratifications. Not everybody agreed with the Vedic way and there were notable differences, such as Buddhism. The Vedic teachings themsevles underwent considerable revaluation and were restated in the more contemplative teachings of the Upanisads. The polytheism of the Vedas is absorbed into the montheistic philosophy of the Vedanta. Vedanta developed into the most refined philosophical system based on the teachings of the Upanisads.

A long spell of Buddhism dominated the Indian subcontinent with Asoka being the most prominent king to be deeply influenced by the Buddha's teachings. A long line of Buddhist scholars and teachers refined the teachings of the buddha and established a distinct school of Buddhism.
In the 8th Century there arose in Kerala a brilliant thinker named Sankara who traveled the length and breadth of India and was able to establish his school of Advaita Vedanta based on the work done by an earlier Guru named Gaudapada whose commentary on the Mandukya Upanisad, called the Mandukya Karika, became the basis for Sankara's own philosophy of non-dualism. With the establishment of Sankara's Advaita Vedanta, Buddhism lost its potency in India.


The next significant cultural pattern was the Islamic empire during Medieval times. This was followed by British colonization in the modern era.

In the course of this mixing and sifting, blast and counterblast, juxtaposition and revaluation, many ideas were gained ascendancy and others declined. A quest for the truth persisted though these outward upheavals and the desire to know the ultimate knowledge continued to inspire the best minds. The perennial questions of "Who am I?" and "Whence the world?" never ceased to engage the intelligent person.

Vedanta became the Weltenshuaagen of the elite, while the grass-root masses preserved their own ritual, folklore and non-vedic traditons. Yoga, Sri Vidya and Tantra belong to the non-vedic sources. While the elite found their solace in abstract and sophisticated philosophy, the grass-root masses happy followed their own patterns of behavior and their own belief systems. It was not possible to ignore the attraction of non-Vedic traditions. It is this tension between a sophisticated elite culture and the popularity of grass-root movements that is resolved by Sankara in the Saundarya Lahari.

Saundarya Lahari, "The Upsurging Billows of Beauty" is a composition by Shankara. It is in Sanskrit and consists of 100 verses.

Ever since serious scholars have studied the Saundarya Lahari, there have been controversy about the authorship of this work. Sankara is a staunch Advaita Vedantin and a composer of many Sanskrit classical works including commentaries on the major Upanisads and the Bhagavad Gita.

The Saundarya Lahari is a poem in praise of the Universal Goddess, or Shakti. The work is rich in images, metaphor and allegory and hence it roused a lot of controversy about the authorship of Sankara. While Advaita Vedanta speaks of the highest as having no form or name, the Saundarya Lahari describes the beauty of the feminine form.

Nataraja Guru confirms that the Saundarya Lahari is indeed a composition of Sankara and he also gives us the insight that the work is written in proto-language which is the primordial form of communication using symbols. The other works by Sankara are written in meta-language, which is language about language. Today symbolic language presents to us a new possibility of communicating as the world gets rushed and there is lack to time to read through voluminous texts.

Once the work is seen as a proto-linguistic expression it begins to reveal the possibility of teaching Vedanta through the symbols of Beauty.

Advaita Vedanta is the culmination of an inquiry that has its basis in the Upanisads. Earlier in the Vedas there are references to the Ultimate Being. This notion is developed in the Upanisads.

Saundarya is Beauty. Lahari is the Upsurging billow. Beauty can be represented in several ways. In the mineral world we have gems as the most beautiful; in the botanical world it is flower that is considered most beautiful; and in the human world the woman is considered most beautiful.

SPIRITUAL RESOURCES TO NAVIGATE CLIMATE CHANGE

-- Vyasa Prasad --

Mystic Messages Beyond Time and Clime

One is beyond what can be counted,
the other is ordinary; other than these two there is not any other form
existing in waking, or in dream,
or in some city of the gods; this is certain.
Atmopadesa Satakam V. 67 (Narayana Guru)

The Tao that can be told
is not the eternal Tao
The name that can be named
is not the eternal Name.
The unnameable is the eternally real
Naming is the origin
of all particular things.
Tao Te Ching, V.1 (Lao Tzu)

There was a door to which I found no key,
There was a veil past which I could not see,
Some little talk awhile of me and thee,
There seem'd -- and then no more of thee and me.  
Rubaiyyat of Omar Khayyam V. 32

When Self-knowledge (atma-vidya) shrinks,
then ignorance is fearful;
substantiation by name and form,
in the most terrible fashion, looms here, ghostlike.
Darshana Mala, Ch.1 V.7 (Narayana Guru)

We take long trips.
We puzzle  over the meaning of a painting or a book,
when what we're wanting to see and understand
in this world, we are that.
     Jelaluddin Rumi, Quatrain 549

Earth is the Mother; and we are her children.  
Atharva Veda

Backward Glances - Causal Speculation

Emerging out of the Dark Ages the thinkers of the 18th century European Enlightenment laid the foundation for the scientific revolution that would transform the entire world.  The shackles of dogma had already been weakened by Copernicus and Giordano Bruno. But as reason gained ascendency over faith, a schism developed between  spirit and matter.  The philosophies of Descartes, Locke and Newton encouraged materialists to dominate nature with their culture and dominate feelings with reason.  Matter came under the purview of the scientists, while spirit was relegated to the realm of religious experiences.  The physical world investigated with empirical instruments became the domain of science, while the metaphysical realm beyond the reach of measurement became the concern of religions.  The divorce of faith from  reason sowed the seeds for conflict centuries later. 

Western  desire and means to control and dominate nature gradually spread around the world through the industrial revolution, international trade and colonization.  In due course the schism between spirit and matter became established in the minds of leading thinkers of the modern era, and the "objective" "demonstrable" and the "a posteriori" came to be accepted as the most reliable form of knowledge.   Seeing is believing.  

The East never created a schism between the world of experience and the realm of transcendence.  Both were understood as two aspects of the same Ultimate Reality.   The Rishis of the Upanishads composed rhapsodic hymns in praise of the Supreme Spirit, which is at once the transcendental and the immanent.   The objective world of experience is a projection of one's own consciousness.  We see what we believe.  


SPIRITUAL RESOURCES TO NAVIGATE CLIMATE CHANGE

Thus the cultures of the East and the West developed two civilizations: that which resonates and is one with all earthly manifestations, and that which denies sentience, spirit and psyche to all elements exterior to humankind.  At the same time, western society's notion of liberty, equality and fraternity liberated the rigidly hierarchical societies of the east.  The dismantling of ancient social structures has not yet been fully accomplished and the east is in the process of assimilating change and coping with the interim chaos as centuries old established modes of life begin to collapse and new possibilities emerge. 

In "The Relation of the Individual to the Universe", Tagore writes, "The civilization of ancient Greece was nurtured within city walls.  In fact, all the modern civilizations have their cradles of brick and mortar.  These walls leave their mark deep in the minds of men.  They set up a principle of 'divide and rule' in our mental outlook, which begets in us a habit of securing all our conquests by fortifying them and separating them from one another.  We divide nation and nation, knowledge and knowledge, man and nature.  It breeds in us a strong suspicion of whatever is beyond the barriers we have built, and everything has to fight hard for its entrance into our recognition."

In contrast to the civilizations cradled in brick and mortar we have the way of the rishis and druids living in forest hermitages or wandering freely, neither sowing nor reaping, nor storing in barns, living in absolute freedom, sustained by the benevolence of Providence.  It was from these forest communities and desert retreats that the wisdom heritage of the world emerged. Wisdom teachers have continuously affirmed the oneness of consciousness, happiness, knowledge, god and the Self. These are not disjunct values, but aspects of one essence.  
In the light of Tagore's observation, modern democracy is inherently flawed in favor of  urban dwellers and the culture of opulence.

Neurotheology, an emerging interdisciplinary field of neurological and spiritual studies, is demonstrating that the human brain is uniquely constructed to perceive and generate spiritual realities.  Left to themselves humans are naturally spiritual, while the influence of urbanization might actually fracture spiritual capability.  Natural spirituality  corresponds with the Upanishadic dictum, Tat Tvam Asi, "That Thou Art" and the principle of the via negativa followed by the 6th century mystic Dionysius the Areopagite and the Vedantins of India as well as the Negative Education of Rousseau.    





Epistemological Framework

An overall epistemology takes both the Beyond and the Ordinary together into consideration and deals with the problem in a wholesale manner, rather than dealing with a piecemeal annexation of one aspect  disjunct from the whole.  We cannot treat the problem as an event "out there" without a corresponding awareness "within". Contemporary lifestyle has interfered with natural laws and so climate change may be considered as the outer manifestation of an inner ethical problem of human beings.


 
Many insights are shrouded in the  lingua mystica of the ancients and need to be restated in the lingua scientific of the modern world.  In this task we are confronted with a very fundamental problem -- that of the alphabet itself.  David Abram in his book "The Spell of the Sensuous" blames the invention of the phonetic alphabet for triggering a trend towards increasing abstraction and alienation from nature.  He writes, "Only as the written text began to speak would the voices of the forest, and of the river, begin to fade.  And only then would language loosen its ancient association with the invisible breath, the spirit sever itself from the wind, the psyche dissociate itself from the environing air."  Another author, Leonard Shlain in his book "The Alphabet Verses The Goddess"  points out the difference between images which are concrete and are perceived in an all-at-once manner, and alphabets which are abstract, with symbols arranged in a linear sequence.  To perceive images the brain uses wholeness, simultaneity and synthesis.  To get the meaning of alphabetic writing the brain relies on sequence, analysis and abstraction.  Both authors agree that alphabetical writing altered the neurobiology of the brain to severe human  connection with the natural world.  The poet and the artist is able to capture the essence, while the scientist struggles in vain. While technology  has created a new culture of virtual spaces and mass communication,  there is a silver lining in the  reemergence of symbolic language through cinema, television and computer graphics.  We see rudimental symbolic language in the use of the color scheme in traffic lights and identical icons on signboards in airports across the world.  Power Point presentations have become ubiquitous.  The emergence of the Vook integrates video with written text. As eBooks become popular, there is a possibility of new genres of
animated picture-written-word literature. In these instances symbolism offers a new language of secularism. And when we dream we enter a realm of symbolic language.   We may be at the threshold of another neurobiological transformation, this time by reviving the ancient human relationship with symbols.  



The iconography and symbolic pictographs of the ancient world used protolanguage based on images.  These cultures are known to be egalitarian,  natural, with considerable harmony between the genders.  One of the best examples of such an egalitarian society is the Harappan civilization.  The anthropologist Jonathan Kenoyer has studied the Indus Valley Civilization, and he writes,  "The Indus cities did not grow up around a central palace or temple, as was common with other early states.  There is no evidence of elite burials filled with material wealth.  Perhaps the most striking feature is the small amount of evidence for military conflict and not a single depiction of warfare or captive taking...From these early times, people decided how to organize their settlements, how to interact with other communities, how to resolve conflicts, what to do with surplus food and wealth and how to pass on knowledge from one generation to the next."    They used images extensively in the form of seals and symbols (which are yet to be deciphered).  Today we can experience the mystique of iconography in statues of the dancing Nataraja, among many others. 





In the Indian philosophical tradition there are four means of obtaining valid knowledge.  1. Direct Perception; 2. Inference; 3. Comparison; and 4. Word Testimony.  The first three means are useful in the transactional world while a priori word testimony, shabda,  is the means to gain transcendental knowledge.  

Like students of mathematics  willing to accept the abstract notion "x", let us  accept the a priori normative notion that the Eternal Spirit pervades the universe, including the individual self. The Isavasya Upanishad says, "Isavasya idam sarvam" the Lord pervades all this.  The spirit is indestructible  pure consciousness,  beyond the reach of climate change or global warming.  This is the One Beyond of Narayana Guru, the Eternal Tao of the Taoists, and the Mysterium Tremendum of Omar Khayyam.  Nothing can bring about the destruction of This which knows no decrease, according to the Bhagavad Gita (Ch.2 v.17.)   

Having established our a priori foundation, let us now deal with our a posteriori knowledge of climate change and the looming apocalypse of global warming.  This is the realm of the ordinary of Guru Narayana,  the place of a little talk  of me and thee of Khayyam, and  the realm of  particular things of the Taoists.  This is where we find ourselves when Self-Knowledge shrinks. This is the world where we seek our daily bread. 

It is in this world that human beings should act as good stewards, managing their natural resources with care.  Instead their actions are  careless, bringing destruction to the world along with the natural habitat of myriad other living creatures.  Narayana Guru observed, 'It would not have mattered so much if the effect of man's misdeeds struck its blow only at mankind. But the innocent monkeys and birds in the forest have to forfeit their peaceful life because of man. The rest of Nature would be thankful if, in the process of self-destruction, man would have the good sense to destroy himself if he must, alone, leaving the rest of creation at least to the peace which is its birthright...'







Methodology

Between the edict of a dictator and the tantrum of a child we have the possibility of a mature dialogue.  Both dialogue and dialectic have the same Greek root, dialegesthai, meaning "converse with".  Dialectical understanding takes both the counterparts in a situation into consideration.    The activist on the street is the counterpart of the meditator seated in a Zendo.  One is active, the other is contemplative.  Their apparent mutually contradictory stands are  cancelled by intuitively understanding the common ground they share, which is their intentionality and their goal.  The meeting point of opposites is a non-polarized neutral position where they cancel each other out.  Cancellation does not yield horizontal gain or loss, but a vertical value of satisfaction.  The transcendent (One beyond) and the immanent (the ordinary) intersect and function in and through the living experience of every person.  One cannot escape into the transcendental spirit and at the same time continue his or her existential life.  Neither can existential life be devoid of the transcendental element.  Reducing environmental pollution will enhance the transcendental in the here and now.  

Spiritual Resources
Our first resource is abhaya, fearlessness.  We resolve to be courageous and use our creative intelligence.  The only thing to fear is fear itself.
The second resource is satyam, truth.  A transparent vision should guide our understanding.  Truth should be the foundation of thought, word and deed.  A corollary to truth is dharma, the innate principle that gives integrity to everything. 
The third resource is jnana, knowledge.  We must have reliable sources of knowledge so that half-baked notions and superstition are kept at abeyance.  The world we experience is not real as such, but a phenomena created by the relationship between coexisting  opposing forces.  The blue of the sky, for instance, does not exist, per se.  It is a phenomena generated by the interaction between invisible rays of light with invisible particles in the atmosphere.  When the sun is near the horizon, light rays elongate and blue turns to red.  We cannot see the invisible photons or atmospheric particles which are the cause, and we see only the effect which is the blue color of the sky.  Climate change is an effect that is thought to have an anthropogenic cause.  Interdisciplinary thinking is better than compartmentalized specialization. Buckminster Fuller said that specialization precludes comprehensive thinking.  
The fourth resource is ahimsa, non-violence.  Human beings should respect nature and hold all natural processes in awe and reverence.  Nature is a symbiotic interactive system.  Interdependence is the modus operandi.  Her hierarchy  develops from simple structures to intricate  complexity in a spiraling centrifugal manner.  Nature is self-replicating and proliferates manifoldly.    It is a self-governing and self-regulating system, with inbuilt homeostasis and cybernetic feedback loops that affect self-correction.  Paradoxically, nature functions in a perennial state of imbalance.  It is therefore impossible to control nature and unwise to interfere with her inherent intelligence.  
The fifth resource is tapas, effort.  All accomplishments require sustained effort.  One should not feel disheartened and should be willing to apply oneself diligently until the goal is attained. 
The sixth resource is damyata, self-restraint.  Restrain the addiction to control and dominate, and restrain the urge  to enjoy at the expense of the environment or by exploiting fellow human beings. Aggressive extroversion  needs to be tempered with sobering introversion. The ego creates a boundary by assuming the role of knower, doer and enjoyer. 
The seventh resource is datta, being charitable.  Sharing and giving spreads wealth.  A need based system of equitable distribution  should replace the current economic model propped with  banking cartels and unfair trading practices.    There is enough food to feed the world and enough goods to cater to everybody's needs.  Economic imbalances need to be set right for a just and fair world.  
The eighth resource is daya, compassion.  Human transactions should be touched with an element of kindliness and compassion.  Cruelty to the planet, plants and animals and to ourselves and fellow human beings should be sublimated into  a compassionate attitude towards all sentient and non-sentient beings.  
The ninth resource is saundarya, beauty.  Nature is beautiful.  The starry heavens above, the snowy mountains below, the colorful flora and the captivating fauna around us are alluring.  Aesthetics should infuse our sensory world, elevating our consciousness and refining our emotions.  The artist Paul Gaugin lamented, "There is always a heavy demand for fresh mediocrity.  In every generation the least cultivated taste has the largest appetite."  Quality rather than quantity should be the norm. 
The tenth resource is tyaga, relinquishment.  Ultimately everything passes away and perishes.  Instead of clinging and holding on, it is wise to  let go of things and ideas that have served their usefulness.   Static and closed attitudes should transform into dynamic and open states of mind.  

Transformation

It is ironic that scientific progress has led us to an age when an impending apocalypse has become a unifying force.  This enantiodromia  is an opportunity to  move forward towards the greater challenge of understanding consciousness --  the inner environment, or inner landscape, that is shared by all of humanity. The cosmos and the psychos are interlaced to create the grand universe, understood objectively "out there" and subjectively "within" by all sentient beings.     
The complexity of geodialectics with power plays between nations was evident when world leaders gathered at the United Nations summit on Climate Change in Copenhagen recently.    Climate change has been given due recognition at the highest of international forums. But arriving at consensus and or even fully understanding the complex nature of the issue seems to have eluded influential governments, encouraging concerned individuals to take for climate change in their own hands. Google Earth announced that it is adding new features that will allow users to "view" any location on earth up till the year 2100, according to both the  Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change's high and low emissions scenarios.  This feature empowers every desktop and laptop computer user to become a Climate Change monitor.



The industrial age opened the "Pandora's Box" of sequestered carbon buried in the earth for millennia.
Nobody thought of managing the tons of carbon released into the atmosphere by burning fossil fuels.
This shows the one-sided approach of science and technology.  




New engineering is necessary to  mitigate disaster with the help of innovative ideas.  Large rafts of reflective material can prevent the north pole from heating, should  the ice melt.  Geodesic domes can protect entire coastal villages from inundation.  Networks of rural and urban centers can become hubs of transportation, involving the population to mobilize resources, while at the same time localizing  consumption patterns.   Along with the reduction of green house gases, disaster management strategies need to be put into place.  

Conclusion

Lasting peace at the personal and interpersonal levels is the ideal foundation for human happiness and well being.  Meaning is important to satisfy the spiritual nature of human beings.  Our answers have to be in the context of the perennial questions of Why are we here?  Where have we come from? and Where are we going?  Only by addressing the ultimate questions do we find the final solution.  

References

Atmopadesa Satakam
100 Verses on Self-Instruction by Narayana Guru

Tao Te Ching
Lao Tze (Translated  by Stephen Mitchell)

Rubaiyyat of Omar Khayyam
(Translation by Edward Fitzgerald)

Open Secret - Versions of Rumi
by John Moyne and Coleman Barks

Darsana Mala
Garland of Visions by Narayana Guru

Word of the Guru
Nataraja Guru

The Bible

Sadhana
by Tagore

The Spell of the Sensuous
by David Abram

The Alphabet Verse The Goddess
by Leonard Shlain

How God Changes Your brain
Andrew Newberg and Mark Robert Waldman

Ancient Cities of the Indus Valley Civilization
by Jonathan Mark Kenoyer

Isavasya Upanishad
Bhagavad Gita

Buckminster Fuller
Quotations

Spiritual Resources from
Bhagavad Gita
Patanjali Yoga Sutras
Brhadaranyaka Upanishad, Khila Kanda.
_______________



Henri Matisse's Great Leap Forward

Henri Matisse's Great Leap Forward